Methodologies, standards and regulatory initiatives must be harmonised for voluntary carbon markets to work efficiently

27 February 2024

Two important carbon-related announcements were made in late February. 

The first was issued by the European Council and European Parliament who reached a provisional political agreement to establish the first EU-level certification framework for permanent carbon removals, carbon farming and carbon storage in products. The voluntary framework is intended to facilitate and speed up the deployment of high-quality carbon removal and soil emission reduction activities in the EU. 

The second announcement was from the Voluntary Carbon Market Integrity Initiative (VCMI), highlighting that Bain & Company became the first organisation to make a successful Carbon Integrity Platinum Claim. This Platinum Claim, the highest level of Carbon Integrity Claims, necessitates the purchase and retirement of high-quality carbon credits in an amount equal to or greater than 100% of a company’s residual emissions.

These two exciting announcements, coupled with IOSCO’s “Good Practises” for promoting the integration and orderly functioning of Voluntary Carbon Markets (VCMs), and the ICVCM and VCMI partnership declaration at COP28, underscore the importance of global standards in our pursuit of climate neutrality. 

However, the voluntary carbon activities landscape is not without its challenges. Despite the urgency of immediate action, the emergence of competing registries advocating unique and isolated methodologies poses a risk of introducing complex and hierarchical burdens on both sellers and buyers. This has created confusion in the market, leading to a decrease in liquidity. There is a consensus that high-integrity carbon credits, especially those focusing on removal and long-term storage, are essential.

To address this challenge, Tokenovate’s asset-agnostic trading lifecycle management platform enables carbon project owners not only to tokenise their assets but also to manage them for the duration of their lifetime. A powerful feature of the platform is its carbon project origination and classification engine, that through machine-learning seamlessly guides project owners to achieve compliance with both the methodologies of registries and standards, such as ICVCM. The engine output is not only a high-fidelity schema for the project owner but also a tokenised on-chain master project file that can be verified by a registry and made ready for digital issuance to trading venues.

The development and acceptance of fit-for-purpose carbon removal standards will not only boost green technology development but also instil market confidence in high-integrity carbon credits. We applaud these commendable initiatives and support efforts to devise solutions that drive us toward carbon neutrality. Nevertheless, we believe more efforts are necessary, which is why we are collaborating with project owners, enabling technology providers and trading venues to accelerate progress effectively.

Note: In May 2023, Tokenovate with our partners GMEX and Zero13 enabled the execution of the world’s first smart contract for VCC derivatives trades using ISDA definitions. Read the announcement here.

Blog

More from the Blog

Read what the team at Tokenovate is researching and discussing at work.View All Posts
Tokenovate Response to HMT Consultation
Date: 22nd May 2025   Tokenovate Response to HMT Consultation on the Draft Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Regulated Activities and Miscellaneous Provisions) (Cryptoassets) Order 2025   Tokenovate welcomes the opportunity to respond to HM Treasury’s consultation on the draft Cryptoasset Statutory Instrument (the SI). As a UK-based start-up building digital financial infrastructure, Tokenovate…
Read Post
Response to CFTC’s Request for Comment on Trading and Clearing Derivatives on a 24/7 Basis
The Honourable Caroline D. Pham Acting Chairman Commodity Futures Trading Commission Three Lafayette Centre 1155 21st Street, NW Washington, DC 20581   Date: 19th May 2025   Re: Request for Comment on Trading and Clearing Derivatives on a 24/7 Basis   Dear Acting Chairman Pham,  Tokenovate appreciates the opportunity to respond to the Commodity Futures…
Read Post
A New Giovannini Moment for European Capital Markets?
Tokenovate’s Response to the Draghi Report and the European Commission’s Savings and Investments Union Proposal.   Earlier this year, Richard Baker, Founder and CEO of Tokenovate, and Ciarán McGonagle, Chief Legal & Product Officer,  met with senior members of the Directorate-General for Financial Stability, Financial Services and Capital Markets Union (DG FISMA) in Brussels. Over…
Read Post